Problem with If else statement

Problem with If else statement - Printable Version

+- Python Forum (https://python-forum.io)
+-- Forum: Python Coding (https://python-forum.io/forum-7.html)
+--- Forum: General Coding Help (https://python-forum.io/forum-8.html)
+--- Thread: Problem with If else statement (/thread-29364.html)

Problem with If else statement - Milfredo - Aug-30-2020

I am building an application. And The following code works fine when Button first clicked. But next time button clicked, I get no change. I don't get an error, just get nothing,...the "On: does not change to "Off"

def set_drfvalue():
	on = 0
	if on == 0:

		drf_label = Label(factor_build,text= "On",  fg= "#581003", font = ("sans_serif  10 bold")).place(x =130, y=25)
		on = 1
	else:
		
		drf_label2 = Label(factor_build,text= "Off",  fg= "#581003", font = ("sans_serif  10 bold")).place(x =130, y=25)
		on = 0

def build_factors():
   my_button20 = Button(factor_build, text = "DRF Speed", width = 15, command = set_drfvalue) 
   my_button20.place(x=10, y=25)

I know I must be missing something. But followed a video to a T and no go.

Thank You

RE: Problem with If else statement - bowlofred - Aug-30-2020

What is line 2 there for? Because it is there, the else block will never be reached.

If on is supposed to be a global variable visible outside the function, you will need to declare it as a global.

If it's not supposed to be outside the function, you might want to create a closure. Then you don't have to initialize the variable every time it's called.

RE: Problem with If else statement - Pleiades - Aug-30-2020

Can you post the video Milfredo, maybe different eyes can spot something you did not code properly from the video. Line 2 does look odd.

RE: Problem with If else statement - Milfredo - Aug-30-2020

I see the problem. Yes each time the button gets clicked variable gets reset to 0. So question then is how do I initialize the variable?

Thanks

RE: Problem with If else statement - deanhystad - Aug-30-2020

The best thing to do is use a a control that displays state. If a button toggles something between zero and 1, the button should display the state of the thing it toggles. That way you don't need a separate display. A checkbox would be a good choice. This is a good user interface design thing and not a Python or tkinter thing.

To do what you want to do you need a persistent variable. In your function set_drfvalue() the variable "on" only exists while the function is running. Once set_drfvalue() is done, "on" is g"on"e. To make "on" persistent we we need to move "on" out of drfvalue.

This is the easiest solution, but it is really bad.

drfvalue = 0

def toggle_drfvalue():
    global drfvalue 
    if drfvalue  == 0:
        drf_label = Label(factor_build,text= "On",  fg= "#581003", font = ("sans_serif  10 bold")).place(x =130, y=25)
    else:      
        drf_label2 = Label(factor_build,text= "Off",  fg= "#581003", font = ("sans_serif  10 bold")).place(x =130, y=25)
    drfvalue = (drfvalue + 1) % 2
 
def build_factors():
   my_button20 = Button(factor_build, text = "DRF Speed", width = 15, command = toggle_drfvalue) 
   my_button20.place(x=10, y=25)

We made "on" a variable in the module namespace. Since "on" is no longer contained by a function it will persist after the function is done running. We had to rename "on" because it had a terrible name that means nothing when defined outside the scope of set_drfvalue(). We had to initialize "on" to a value. And whe have to tell toggle_drfvalue() that it should look in the module namespace for "on" (now drfvalue).

This solution works fine for 1 button and 1 variable. Things get ugly when you have a dozen controls and a dozen variables and unusable when you have hundreds of controls and hundreds of variables. I was shocked to discover the last system I worked on has over 1000 different controls and displays. It isn't even that big of a system. Using global would not work for something like that.

If you want to toggle something, use a checkbox.

RE: Problem with If else statement - Milfredo - Aug-30-2020

Thank you. Problem is I have coded 60 factor buttons. Previous version had checkboxes but they took up too much room. I have another 10 to 20 factors that must be accounted for in the near future. I will see if I can come up with a work around and maybe create a list and append every time a button is clicked.

Thank you very much.