Refutation of the Euler hypothesis

Refutation of the Euler hypothesis - Printable Version

+- Python Forum (https://python-forum.io)
+-- Forum: Python Coding (https://python-forum.io/forum-7.html)
+--- Forum: Homework (https://python-forum.io/forum-9.html)
+--- Thread: Refutation of the Euler hypothesis (/thread-40230.html)

Refutation of the Euler hypothesis - Vitulus - Jun-24-2023

Problem with completing the task.
good time of day. In the process of learning programming in the Python environment, I encountered the problem of incorrect calculation. The problem being solved, the refutation of the Euler hypothesis. the following code is written for the solution:

for a in range(1, 150):
    for b in range(a, 150):
        for c in range(b, 150):
            for d in range(c, 150):
                e = ((a ** 5) + (b ** 5) + (c ** 5) + (d ** 5)) ** 0.2
                if e == int(e):
                    print(a, b, c, d, e, a + b + c + d + e)
if e != int(e):
    print('NO')

answer:

Output:
"NO"

The result of code execution, no solution. But this is not true. After studying this topic, the required numbers were found. Put numbers in the code:

a = 27
b = 84
c = 110
d = 133
e = (a ** 5) + (b ** 5) + (c ** 5) + (d ** 5)
a = e ** (1 / 5)
b = a ** 5
print(e, a, b )

answer:

Output:
61917364224 144.00000000000003 61917364224.00006

Wrong decision again, please explain what the error is. I can't figure out the problem without qualified help. Thank you in advance for an exhaustive answer!

RE: Refutation of the Euler hypothesis - jefsummers - Jun-24-2023

Looks like the problem is with floating point approximation. Floating point in not precise, which is why you get 144.000...3.

RE: Refutation of the Euler hypothesis - Gribouillis - Jun-24-2023

You need to find a more reliable way to determine whether an integer is the fifth power of another integer. The rounding error of floating point numbers when you take the power 0.2 is the cause of your problem.