import module with syntax error

[Skaperen]

i'm importing a module that may have errors in the source code. i tried to catch it like:

1 2 3 4

try:     import flaky except ImportError:     print('bad module')

but it gave me SyntaxError instead. ImportError didn't cover it. how can i find all the exceptions i might need to cover?

[bowlofred]

The imported file will be compiled (so may raise SyntaxError) and will be executed. Good modules will try to limit what is executed (putting most things in __init()__ or methods rather than in the main script). But that means that theoretically the code could raise any error.

If the only thing you're worried about is bad code/SyntaxError, then just catch that. I'm struggling to think of similar errors that would be raised by the compiler/interpreter rather than the code within (but maybe someone else will know of other situations).

If you're going to use the exception to fail with a nice message rather than continue, then catching Exception and reporting it seems reasonable.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

import sys try:     import flakey except Exception as e:     print("Failed to complete import.  Cancelled.")     print(type(e), e)     sys.exit(1)

[Skaperen]

i'm wondering what else there is besides SyntaxError. i've seen some other errors in the code before. i am wanting to know what are all the possible exceptions that could be raised.

[bowlofred]

Technically any exception can be raised on an import (including those that are in the standard library as well as custom exceptions). But if you look at the built-in Exceptions, the only two errors that call out being raised on import are ImportError and SyntaxError.

What is your intent with catching the SyntaxError? What do you want the program to do when the import fails?

[buran]

But if you look at the built-in Exceptions, the only two errors that call out being raised on import are ImportError and SyntaxError.

Another one that comes to my mind is IndentationError.

[bowlofred]

Yes, but that's a subclass. So catching SyntaxError will catch IndentationError as well.

[Skaperen]

What is your intent with catching the SyntaxError? What do you want the program to do when the import fails?

that is mostly undecided. it will initially be some error message to the user. that's how i plan to initially test it.

[Skaperen]

ah... since import runs the code, too, that does open up any exception.