how does "is" work ?

[luoheng]

I met a strange problem when using is. Here is the code:

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

>> i = "12" >> j = "12" >> i is j True >> i = "1 2" >> j = "1 2" >> i is j False

When I move the code to a file, the output will be True True. What happened?

[Evil_Patrick]

"==" operator compares by checking for equality

"is" operator compares identities

[luoheng]

"==" operator compares by checking for equality "is" operator compares identities

I know the definition of is. Here I want to know why is returns different results with different strings("12" and "1 2"), and why the results differ in IDE and file.

[perfringo]

It's always good to start with built-in help (>>> help('is'). You can verify whether your belief that you know definition of 'is' is truthy:

From aforementioned help:

Identity comparisons
====================

The operators "is" and "is not" test for object identity: "x is y" is
true if and only if *x* and *y* are the same object. Object identity
is determined using the "id()" function. "x is not y" yields the
inverse truth value.

Also I don't understand the claim: 'When I move the code to a file, the output will be True True.' This code doesn't have any output if you run it from file (no print statement)

[luoheng]

It's always good to start with built-in help (>>> help('is'). You can verify whether your belief that you know definition of 'is' is truthy: From aforementioned help:

Identity comparisons ==================== The operators "is" and "is not" test for object identity: "x is y" is true if and only if *x* and *y* are the same object. Object identity is determined using the "id()" function. "x is not y" yields the inverse truth value.

Also I don't understand the claim: 'When I move the code to a file, the output will be True True.' This code doesn't have any output if you run it from file (no print statement)

Sorry, I should make my problem clear.
in python commandline, I define two same strings and use is to identify whether they are the same object. Just like you see above, sometimes they are (like 12), Sometimes not (like 1 2). But when I move all the code to a file, they are always the same object.
I want to know when strings are the same object and why result differs in commandline and file ? Here is the code in test file:

1 2 3 4 5 6

i = "12" j = "12" print(i is j) i = "1 2" j = "1 2" print(i is j)

The output is True True, while in commandline, it's True False.

[buran]

from the docs

Types affect almost all aspects of object behavior. Even the importance of object identity is affected in some sense: for immutable types, operations that compute new values may actually return a reference to any existing object with the same type and value, while for mutable objects this is not allowed. E.g., after a = 1; b = 1, a and b may or may not refer to the same object with the value one, depending on the implementation, but after c = []; d = [], c and d are guaranteed to refer to two different, unique, newly created empty lists. (Note that c = d = [] assigns the same object to both c and d.)

in your example you use str (i.e. immutable type) so there is no guarantee both variable will point to same object.