Failure in writing binary text to file

[Gigux]

I would like to write some text to file but coded as binary so that the text is not immediately visible with a text editor.
I followed this tutorial, but:

Output:
# in python3
with open('mybinfile.bin', 'wb') as fl:
    text = 'Hello InfinityQuest!'
    fl.write(text.encode('utf-8'))
# in shell
$ cat mybinfile.bin 
Hello InfinityQuest!

So there has been no encoding.
What is the right way to write text to a binary file?

[Gribouillis]

If you encode an ascii string with the UTF-8 encoding, it does not change a single byte. For non ascii characters there are more bytes.

>>> "Hello InfinityQuest!".encode('utf-8')
b'Hello InfinityQuest!'
>>> "hétérogénéité".encode('utf-8')
b'h\xc3\xa9t\xc3\xa9rog\xc3\xa9n\xc3\xa9it\xc3\xa9'

Your way to write binary files is perfect.

[bowlofred]

If you want the text to be hard to read, you'll need a different encoding than UTF-8, and you'll need an encoding that an editor won't randomly understand (like UTF-16).

You could run it through base64 before writing it out.

>>> import base64
>>> "Hello InfinityQuest!".encode()
b'Hello InfinityQuest!'
>>> base64.b64encode("Hello InfinityQuest!".encode())
b'SGVsbG8gSW5maW5pdHlRdWVzdCE='
>>> base64.b64decode(b'SGVsbG8gSW5maW5pdHlRdWVzdCE=')
b'Hello InfinityQuest!'
>>> base64.b64decode(b'SGVsbG8gSW5maW5pdHlRdWVzdCE=').decode()
'Hello InfinityQuest!'

[Gigux]

Thank you for the tips. I tried the following:

import base64

text = base64.b64encode("Hello InfinityQuest!".encode())
print(text)
print("writing")
with open('mybinfile.bin', 'wb') as fl:
    fl.write(text)
print("done")

and I got:

Output:
b'SGVsbG8gSW5maW5pdHlRdWVzdCE='
writing
done
$ cat mybinfile.bin 
SGVsbG8gSW5maW5pdHlRdWVzdCE=

The encoding is done, it looked binary within python, but then the file -- despite the extension -- is read as text with cat. I then tried to further encode in binary directly:

with open('mybinfile.bin', 'wb') as fl:
    fl.write(text.encode('utf-16'))
print("done")

but I got:

Error:
b'SGVsbG8gSW5maW5pdHlRdWVzdCE='
writing
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "./emailer.py", line 11, in <module>
    fl.write(text.encode('utf-16'))
AttributeError: 'bytes' object has no attribute 'encode'

and if I try to write directly as:

with open('mybinfile.bin', 'w') as fl:
    # fl.write(text.encode('utf-16'))
    fl.write(text)
print("done")

I get:

Error:
b'SGVsbG8gSW5maW5pdHlRdWVzdCE='
writing
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "./emailer.py", line 11, in <module>
    fl.write(text)
TypeError: write() argument must be str, not bytes

Essentially, cat should not be able to read the bin file (or return random ASCII codes), if possible.
What am I missing?

[Gribouillis]

Are you trying to encrypt the file? Can you explain the goal of all this?

[Gigux]

Yes, it is a kind of encryption. I would like to avoid that somebody could simply use a text editor or xat to read the file. I could encrypt with some specific shell-based apps, but I am looking for simple implementation in python. I thought that writing a binary would do the trick...

[ndc85430]

Encoding (whether base 64 or otherwise) is not encryption. See, e.g. this.

[Gigux]

Fair enough, so it is really encryption I am after. Thank you